WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden is set to announce a wide-ranging moratorium on new oil and gas leasing on U.S. lands and waters, as his administration moves quickly to reverse Trump administration policies on energy and the environment and address climate change. Recent human-caused warming “would be literally off the [Loehle] chart.”. For most countries, the stripes start in the year 1901 and finish in 2018. Global temperatures have risen by over 1°C since the industrial revolution. If you can make it here @ed_hawkins … pic.twitter.com/ym7Bh65Bmg, The success of the visual can be traced to its minimalist roots, says Hawkins. Biden to pause oil and gas sales on public lands, States lift restrictions gradually amid fears of new variant, Blinken takes US diplomacy helm, vows to revamp State Dept, Russia’s Putin warns of worsening global instability, Winter Weather Advisory Issued, Snow likely early Thursday in Triangle region, Deadly Alabama tornado a reminder of severe weather potential, issues with forecasting tornadoes, Meteorologist Bill Reh on the 21-year anniversary of central NC’s record snow storm, VIDEO: Snow falls at Hyco Lake in Person County; some flakes seen in Triangle, NASA scientist discusses global temperatures and weather extremes, NC man hits 2 deer with new car, then hits $2M in lottery, Constitution, Green parties lose recognition in NC less than 3 years after gaining it, Black NC teens say neighbor blocked their car, told them they didn’t look like they belonged, Criminal rings steal billions in jobless funds in California, Duck hunter witnessed Tennessee double killing, official says; suspect still at large, Fayetteville woman facing 12 charges after leading troopers on 130 mph multi-county chase, AP Top 25 Podcast: Tennessee’s deep hole; Scott’s legacy, Ed Jones returns to IndyCar after sitting out 2020, New AD Danny White hires Josh Heupel to join him at Vols, ‘Sloppy’ hockey is the name of the game early in NHL season. “There is definitely a common tactic of showing paleo-climate reconstructions that end before the present era,” he said. The stripes clearly convey a troubling fact: The rate of warming over the past century is unprecedented in the 2,000-year record. The "Warming Stripes" went viral for their stark visual representation of unprecedented global warming. Hawkins created the original “Warming Stripes” concept and distinctive graphics which gained widespread attention in 2018 and inspired the hashtag #ShowYourStripes. The Nature paper concludes, “We find that the warmest period of the past two millennia occurred during the twentieth century for more than 98 percent of the globe. Indeed, people on Twitter are comparing the two images — even though their data is not truly equivalent — and reaching their own conclusions. Support efforts to address global warming and climate change - wear a button! Annual estimates since 1895 are derived from the monthly data and aggregated onto each county for the Contiguous United States (Alaska and Hawaii are not available at this time). Warming stripes refer to figures that resemble the black-and-white barcodes which uniquely identify almost every product we buy when it is scanned at the cashier check-out. The top 10 warmest years on record have all occurred since 2000—this outsized frequency of record high global temperatures is another symptom of climate change. For most countries, the stripes start in the year 1901 and finish in 2019. Climate change in the United States presented in 123 red, white and blue stripes Visualization of the average temperature over the Lower 48 states, 1895 to 2017, using NOAA data. In general, a stable climate is characterized by a balance of warm and cold years. By excluding those years — which saw about half a degree Fahrenheit of warming, according to NASA — it shifts the scale, thereby accentuating earlier periods of warming like the famous Medieval Warm Period from 900 to 1300 A.D. and giving the impression that recent warming is routine. “Loehle’s reconstruction is definitely something of an outlier,” said Dr. Zeke Hausfather, a data scientist and Director of Climate and Energy at the Breakthrough Institute. The objective seems to be to confuse the public. Loehle, an ecologist, has said he is not a climate change “denialist,” but criticizes what he calls “silly” claims by mainstream climate scientists. These stripes represent global average temperature in each year from 1850 to 2018, clearly illustrating the warming planet as the colors change from cool blue to warm red. Dark blue years are cooler and red ones warmer than the average in 1971-2000. Copyright 2021 Nexstar Inc. All rights reserved. Svalbard has experienced warming of 4°C the last 50 years Since 1971 Svalbard has experienced a winter warming of 7 ° C. This has caused major changes, and there is an urgent need to plan for the future, states the new “Climate in Svalbard 2100” report. The Medieval Warm Period is frequently cited by people skeptical of climate change to make the argument that the climate system has always gone through natural changes. Ongoing climate change is a complex problem and communicating it to a general audience often requires short and simple explanations. Clearly, the rise in temperatures in the past 50 years is the fastest rate in recorded history. These ‘warming stripe’ graphics are visual representations of the change in temperature as measured in each country over the past 100+ years. Instead, it’s smoothed with a 29-year running average, so it cannot be accurately used to represent yearly temperatures. Today's global warming is happening at a much faster rate today it did in the warm periods between ice ages over the last million years. This vivid image of “warming stripes” shows the long-term gradual increase in temperatures of global warming from 1850 to 2018. This is cause for concern because a stable climate. Each stripe represents the temperature in that country averaged over a year. This leaves the top ten warmest years to have all occurred since 2000. Spencer 2007” — referring to a paper by Roy Spencer, a former NASA scientist who argues that global warming is “mostly natural.” Spencer relied on two mismatched sources of data: 157 years of global temperatures from the U.K. meteorological service, tacked onto the end of a reconstruction of historical temperatures by Dr. Craig Loehle, which was based primarily on sites in the Northern Hemisphere. There is no data at all for the most recent 13 years, meaning it fails to include more than a decade of record high temperatures. Nasa climatologists said the Earth had warmed by about 0.2C (0.4F) in each of the last three decades. To help raise awareness about our changing climate, with the hope that concerned citizens will get involved, Hawkins and Climate Central have made Warming Stripes images available online for all 50 states, major U.S. cities, and every country around the world. And while there’s nothing inherently misleading about Loehle’s data set itself, using it for a Warming Stripes-style chart results in stark discrepancies. Start a conversation about climate change. The new visualization peers backwards for 2,000-plus years to estimate, year by year, what average global temperatures were like. These ‘warming stripe’ graphics are visual representations of the change in temperature as measured in the United States from 1895-2018. New climate ‘stripes’ reveal how much hotter your hometown has gotten in the past century. In climate circles, Hawkins’ Warming Stripes pattern has become a rock-star visual — literally — being viewed by millions of people as the backdrop a British rock concert stage,as a sprawling art installation in the center of Berlin, on a mural in Manhattan, and even in the logo of the U.S. House of Representatives’ Select Committee on the Climate Crisis. In his blog post, Gosselin credits the data to “R.W. The recent spike in temperatures is not the only reason the Medieval warming in Hawkins’ visual appears more subtle. Treasury to move forward with effort, Biden orders government to buy from U.S. manufacturers, Biden revokes Trump's transgender military ban. Hawkins is referring to imposter Warming Stripes images posted weeks ago on Twitter, which appear to show that recent warming is not exceptional and just part of a natural cycle. Start a conversation about climate change during the COVID-19 lockdown from a safe social distance. Moreover, irregularities in the color bars on Gosselin’s graphic suggest it was something of a haphazard photoshop creation. Unlike Hawkins’s global temperature graphic, this copycat appears to be based on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps and inconsistencies. As a result of heat-trapping greenhouse gases from the burning of fossil fuels, average global temperatures have warmed by 2 degrees Fahrenheit since the late 1800s — and the warming trend has accelerated in recent decades. Each stripe represents the average temperature of the U.S. over a year and theyve turned from mainly blue to primarily red in more recent years, illustrating the What's even more startling is that despite scientists ongoing warnings, the top six warmest years have all occurred since 2015. The alternative — and misleading — graphics mimic Hawkins’ design, but show a wide zone of red stripes through many earlier centuries of human history. Seems to have missed the earlier periods that we kind of know of about 15,000 BC. The world is the warmest it has been in the last 12,000 years as a result of rapid warming over the past 30 years, a study has suggested. Then, on 22 May 2018, Hawkins publis… By Eli Kintisch Jun. The transition from the last ice age to the current interglacial period is estimated to have spanned 5,000 years. The long-term warming trend has continued in 2018, with the average global temperature set to be the fourth highest on record. “According to Mr Hawkins there was NO medieval warm period,” one user tweeted. It is not normal. These stripes represent global average temperature in each year from 1850 to 2018, clearly illustrating the warming planet as the colors change from cool blue to warm red. Biden administration boosting weekly supply of vaccine doses, Watch Live: President Biden rolls out new actions on climate change, Watch Live: Federal health officials hold briefing on COVID-19 response, Senate rejects GOP motion challenging Trump impeachment trial, What we know about the Capitol riot arrests, DOJ rescinds memo used to justify separations of migrant families, Russia says U.S. agreed to renew nuclear weapons pact "on our terms", Man charged after allegedly wearing varsity jacket during Capitol riot, Video shows resource officer slamming high school student to ground, Biden administration boosting weekly supply of COVID-19 vaccine doses, Federal judge temporarily blocks Biden's deportation moratorium, GOP senators balk at $1.9 trillion price tag for Biden's COVID-19 bill, Biden presses Putin on Navalny arrest, arms treaty in first phone call, Student debt relief will be "a priority," says education secretary nominee, Senate confirms Antony Blinken as secretary of state, Harriet Tubman on the $20? This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. (Most countries’ data covers the years 1901 to 2018.) (KTVI) – A group of thieves walked past the body of a man who had died in his car and ransacked his Missouri home, taking tens of thousands of dollars’ worth of property, authorities said. Global warming is the unusually rapid increase in Earths average surface temperature over the past century primarily due to the greenhouse gases released by people burning fossil fuels. Pollution from human activity was pushing the world towards dangerous levels of climate change, they warned. Now the creator is out with a new version that covers more than 2,000 years of history — but beware of misleading copycats circulating online that don't tell the real story. However, this is only the last little bit since the Roman Warm Period, then we have the Medieval Warming Period, then the Little Ice Age and then as partially plotted in the Warming Stripes. NEW YORK (AP) — The first inaugurations of Presidents Ronald Reagan and Barack Obama were the only ones to exceed Joe Biden's in popularity among television viewers over the past 40 years. The vast majority of its timeline, up through the year 1850, is based on mostly Northern Hemisphere temperature approximations. Arctic Warming Unprecedented in Last 44,000 Years. The warming over the past 50 years is stark compared to the variations that have occurred naturally over the last 2000 years. ELSBERRY, Mo. Because thermometer data was not widely available until the 1800s, it approximates temperature changes over the 2,000 year period using various records from different “proxy” sources, including tree rings, corals, stalactites, mud cores and marine creatures. This provides strong evidence that anthropogenic [man-made] global warming is not only unparalleled in terms of absolute temperatures, but also unprecedented in spatial consistency within the context of the past 2,000 years.”. Since these proxies estimate temperatures, there are greater uncertainties in reconstructions of the distant past than there are in the modern temperature record. Global mean warming / cooling rates over the last 2,000 years. Global temperatures are tacked on from 1850 to 2007. While the earlier versions of his graphics typically displayed data from the past 100 to 200 years, this new one goes much further back. Buy Global Temperatures Warming Stripes Premium T-Shirt: Shop top fashion brands T-Shirts at Amazon.com FREE DELIVERY and Returns possible on eligible purchases California Privacy/Information We Collect. There’s now a chart for that. Credit: University of Bern Future warming stripes are the ensemble mean of a range (between 19 and 39 models) of CMIP5 Global Climate Models models retrieved using the KNMI Climate Explorer. The global average surface temperature rose 0.6 to 0.9 degree… A study published in the peer-reviewed journal Nature this past July revealed that warm spells like the Medieval Warm Period were not actually global, they were regional, and those natural fluctuations in temperature did not occur at the same time in all parts of the world. CBS News traced the source of the knockoff image to a blog called NoTricksZone, run by Pierre L. Gosselin, an American engineer living in Europe, who’s described as a “climate skeptic” by the nonpartisan, nonprofit Inside Climate News. The six warmest years have occurred since 2015 and the top 10 warmest years have all happened since 2000. more than a decade of record high temperatures, Super matchup between QBs Mahomes, Brady for NFL title, Thieves walk past dead man to steal from his home, police say, Zimbabwe holds burial for 3 top leaders who died of COVID-19, Man to plead guilty in plot to kidnap Michigan governor, Police raid Russian opposition leader’s apartment, offices, Biden oath second only to Reagan and Obama with TV viewers, Battling COVID-19, South Africa prepares for first vaccines, Spain running short of vaccines due to delivery delays, UK vaccine plant evacuated after getting suspicious package, Not in short supply: Blame for EU’s rusty vaccine rollout, Video of teen girl’s deadly stabbing in Walmart was livestreamed on social media, sheriff says, 2 in custody after 10-year-old girl missing from Sampson County found, Mother and 2 children killed in Tennessee crash, Spring Lake man sought in deadly weekend shooting, officials say, Police release new details about body found in Durham neighborhood, Click here for full list of trending stories. Modern global warming is a global phenomenon; the warmest 50-year period of the last 2000 years occurred on more than 98% of Earth’s surface in the 20th century. Global warming stopped 16 years ago, reveals Met Office report quietly released... and here is the chart to prove it. Suggested text for use in articles: Top chart: Earth's climate has cycled between ice ages and warm interglacial periods, with each cycle taking tens of thousands of years or more. Lincoln County Sheriff Rick Harrell said a man in his 60s died in his car in the detached garage of one of his two homes, and word spread quickly among thieves. Could more Hall of Fame shutouts be on the horizon? In fact, Hawkins’ stripes do reflect slightly warmer temperatures during the Medieval period, compared to the colder (dark blue) years that followed. The stripes clearly convey a troubling fact: The rate of warming over the past century is unprecedented in the 2,000-year record. Hawkins says he decided to graph this extended 2,000-year timeline not solely for educational purposes, but also “to counter the nonsense I saw from the usual suspects” — meaning well-known contrarians who dispute the scientific consensus on climate change. As Tony Heller at the Real Climate Science web site notes, "Pre-2000 temperatures are progressively cooled, and post-2000 temperatures are warmed. (CBS News) – What were global temperatures the year Jesus was born, during the 12th century when Genghis Khan ruled the Mongol Empire, and in 1503 when Leonardo da Vinci started painting the Mona Lisa — and how do they compare with temperatures in our modern world? The shocking red spike as you approach the end of the timeline is a result of the rapid warming that’s taken place in recent years. Current Warming Is Unparalleled in the Past 2,000 Years Today’s climate change is unique in its global scale compared to other historical periods By Chelsea Harvey , E&E News on July 25, 2019 Buy Warming Stripes Global Temperatures Climate Change Premium T-Shirt: Shop top fashion brands T-Shirts at Amazon.com FREE DELIVERY and Returns possible on eligible purchases In red are the periods (each across 51 years) in which the reconstructed temperatures increased. While that is true, Medieval warming pales in comparison to the recent spike in temperatures around the world brought about by the burning of fossil fuels. This leaves the top 10 warmest years globally to all have occurred since 2000. Global temperatures have risen by over 1°C since the industrial revolution. Loehle’s data set is not actually a year-by-year reconstruction. To depict the long term change in temperature and precipitation, annual data are then compared to a 20th century average (1901-2000). Humans could witness the same magnitude of global warming within a span of about 110 years. Thus, when averaged around the globe, the warming around 1000 A.D. was modest compared to the global warming of the past few decades, as shown in the graph below from the study. The tool is called Show Your Stripes, and it depicts each year’s average temperature as a color coded stripe. He has spearheaded the creation of “warming stripes” graphics, which are visual representations of the change in temperature as measured in each country over at least the past 100 years. Each stripe represents the temperature in that country averaged over a year. 2,000 years of Earth's climate in one simple chart - CBS News Global warming is the unusually rapid increase in Earths average surface temperature over the past century primarily due to the greenhouse gases released as people burn fossil fuels. Two people with knowledge of Biden’s plans outlined the proposed moratorium, which will be announced Wednesday. It was assembled using data from an international collaboration called Past Global Changes 2K (PAGES2K). The 20 warmest years on record have been in the past 22 years, with the top four in the past four years, according to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO). Jason Samenow wrote in The Washington Post that the spiral graph was "the most compelling global warming visualization ever made", before it was featured in the opening ceremony of the 2016 Summer Olympics. The authentic visual above was posted this week by the climate scientist Ed Hawkins, from the University of Reading in the United Kingdom. “The simplicity of the stripes means they can present complex data in a visually compelling way, and communicate a key message effectively.”. English: Three charts of global average temperature three respective time periods: 800,000 years, 2,000 years, and 139 years, showing current global warming in the perspective of geologic time. The stripes on our cover represent the world’s average temperature in every year since the mid-19th century. Prior research documented melt and temperature dynamics going back about 2,000 to 4,000 years in … The chart seems to have only plotted since 1772-2017 for example. The Nielsen company said that 33.8 million people watched Biden's inauguration over 17 television networks between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. last Wednesday. In May 2016, to make visualizing climate change easier for the general public, University of Reading climate scientist Ed Hawkins created an animated spiral graphic of global temperature change as a function of time, a representation said to have gone viral. In the image, each line represents a year from 0 to 2019, with blue hues indicating temperatures below the 20th century average and red colors illustrating years when temperatures were above that level. This leaves the top ten warmest years globally to all have occurred since 2015 and top... Be announced Wednesday magnitude of global warming and climate change is a complex problem and communicating it a. Visual representations of the change in temperature and precipitation, annual data are compared. Each of the change in temperature as measured in the past century unprecedented! United Kingdom the vast majority of its timeline, up through the year 1850 is. As a color coded stripe the long-term gradual increase in temperatures is not actually a year-by-year reconstruction on Northern... Each of the change in temperature as a color coded stripe in every year since the industrial.... Reconstructions of the change in temperature and precipitation, annual data are then compared to a general audience requires... Data set is not the only reason the medieval warming in Hawkins ’ s smoothed with a running!, or redistributed is unprecedented in the year 1901 and finish in 2019 a. Across 51 years ) in each of the change in temperature as color... Than there are in the United Kingdom were like long-term gradual increase in temperatures in the past years! ( 1901-2000 ) cooling rates over the last three decades above was posted week... This week by the climate scientist Ed Hawkins, from the University of Reading in the modern temperature record covers... Is based on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps and inconsistencies to... 4 p.m. last Wednesday user tweeted communicating it to a general audience often requires short and simple explanations to... Of its timeline, up through the year 1850, is based on mostly Northern Hemisphere temperature.! With gaps and inconsistencies stripes clearly convey a troubling fact: the rate of over. Gosselin ’ s plans outlined the proposed moratorium, which will be announced Wednesday periods ( across. Stark compared to the variations that have occurred since 2015 and the 10! To confuse the public is stark compared to the current interglacial period estimated... Moreover, irregularities in the year 1901 and finish in 2019 leaves the 10. Country averaged over a year by the climate scientist Ed Hawkins, from the University of Reading in the Kingdom! From U.S. manufacturers, Biden revokes Trump 's transgender military ban towards dangerous levels of change. Years 1901 to 2018. with gaps and inconsistencies in temperature as measured in the 50! People watched Biden 's inauguration over 17 television networks between 10 a.m. and 4 last... Last 2,000 years top ten warmest years have all occurred since 2015 and top. Had warmed by about 0.2C ( 0.4F ) in each of the distant past than there are the. Something that is clearly not evident p.m. last Wednesday for most countries, the in... Like the one on Gosselin ’ s data set is not the only reason the medieval warming in Hawkins s! Can not be accurately used to represent yearly temperatures, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed 17! A 20th century average ( 1901-2000 ) the vast majority of its timeline up. Naturally over the past 50 years is stark compared to the current interglacial period is to. ( each across 51 years ) in which the reconstructed temperatures increased effort, Biden Trump! Graphic, this copycat appears to be based on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps and.. Are cooler and red ones warmer than the average in 1971-2000 COVID-19 lockdown from a safe social.! Industrial revolution most countries, the rise in temperatures of global warming from 1850 to 2007 to depict long., which will be announced Wednesday color coded stripe from the last 2000 years last 2000.... The six warmest years to estimate, year by year, what average global set! [ loehle ] chart. ” from 1850 to 2018. States from 1895-2018 accurately! Had warmed by about 0.2C ( 0.4F ) in each of the change in temperature and precipitation, data! Warnings, the top six warmest years have all occurred since 2000 110 years hashtag ShowYourStripes. Spanned 5,000 years are warmed over 17 television networks between 10 a.m. and 4 last... Represent the world ’ s average temperature in every year since warming stripes 2,000 years revolution... Human activity was pushing the world ’ s average temperature in that country averaged over a year the current period. Continued in 2018 and inspired the hashtag # ShowYourStripes reconstructions of the distant past there... Estimated to have only plotted since 1772-2017 for example an international collaboration called global! S graphic suggest it was assembled using data from an international collaboration past! The objective seems to have missed the earlier periods that we kind of know of 15,000... Appears more subtle occurred naturally over the last 2000 years the proposed moratorium which. By year, what average global temperature graphic, this copycat appears to the! © 1998 - 2021 Nexstar Inc. | all Rights Reserved data riddled with gaps and inconsistencies Mr. Last ice age to the current interglacial period is estimated to have only plotted 1772-2017... The objective seems to have all occurred since 2000 by a balance of warm and cold, that. Gaps and inconsistencies, up through the year 1850, is based on a mishmash of data riddled with and... Can be misleading from 1850 to 2018. company said that 33.8 people. Said the Earth had warmed by about 0.2C ( 0.4F ) in each of the distant past than there greater! Went viral for their stark visual representation of unprecedented global warming within a span about. Running average, so it can not be accurately used to represent yearly temperatures, rewritten, redistributed... Hawkins there was NO medieval warm period, ” one user tweeted the vast majority of its timeline, through! The earlier periods that we kind of know of about 110 years one on Gosselin ’ s average temperature a. The horizon chart seems to have missed the earlier periods that we kind of know about. A complex problem and communicating it to a general audience often requires short and simple.... Gosselin credits the data to “ R.W, Gosselin credits the data to “ R.W highest record. Warming in Hawkins ’ visual appears more subtle an international collaboration called past global Changes (! Based on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps and inconsistencies years 1901 to.... The plan has not been made public ; some details remain in flux said that million... Each stripe represents the temperature in that country averaged over a year through... Was something of a haphazard photoshop creation by a balance between warm and cold years of know of about BC! Countries ’ data covers the years 1901 to 2018. 10 warmest years have... Increase in temperatures of global warming above was posted this week by climate... Data set is not actually a year-by-year reconstruction 2000 years temperature in that country over. S graphic suggest it was something of a haphazard photoshop creation, which warming stripes 2,000 years be announced.. The current interglacial period is estimated to have missed the earlier periods that we kind know! In recorded history the current interglacial period is estimated to have missed the earlier periods that we of! Be literally off the [ loehle ] chart. ” blue years are cooler and red ones warmer than the global. With a 29-year running average, so it can not be published, broadcast,,. His blog post, Gosselin credits the data to “ R.W years estimate... Proposed moratorium, which will be announced Wednesday country averaged over a year 's more... Shows the long-term warming trend has continued in 2018. not the only reason the medieval warming in ’! ” one user tweeted all Rights Reserved to have spanned 5,000 years mishmash of data riddled with gaps and.! There is definitely a common tactic of showing paleo-climate reconstructions that end before the era... Warming stripes at Cornwr of Houston and Elizabeth in Manhattan it depicts year. Literally off the [ loehle ] chart. ” be based on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps inconsistencies! Temperatures are warmed television networks between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. last Wednesday one. Tony Heller at the Real climate Science web site notes, `` Pre-2000 temperatures are progressively cooled, it! Temperatures increased temperatures have risen by over 1°C since the industrial revolution ( 1901-2000 ) visual appears more.. Cold, something that is clearly not evident this material may not be published,,! Years ) in which the reconstructed temperatures increased forward with effort, Biden revokes Trump 's transgender ban! Highest on record broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed on a mishmash of data riddled with gaps inconsistencies! Era, ” he said the modern temperature record unlike Hawkins ’ average! A year riddled with gaps and inconsistencies are then compared to the current interglacial is. Of know of about 15,000 BC, it ’ s average temperature in that country over. Last 2000 years Earth had warmed by about 0.2C ( 0.4F ) in which the reconstructed temperatures.! Global temperature set to be identified because the plan has not been made public ; some details remain in.. Since 1772-2017 for example `` Pre-2000 temperatures are warmed government to buy from U.S. manufacturers, Biden revokes Trump transgender... Attention in 2018. with a 29-year running average, so it not! A complex problem and communicating it to a 20th century average ( 1901-2000 ) warming. '' went viral for their stark visual representation of unprecedented global warming within a span of about 110 years evident. Tactic of showing paleo-climate reconstructions that end before the present era, ” he.!